By Sydney Marshman, OTD, OTR/L, BCG
A zero-entry shower is often considered the gold standard for accessibility, but it isn't the only way to create a safer bathing environment. For many individuals, the cost, structural changes, or living situation make a full bathroom renovation unrealistic.
Fortunately, there are practical alternatives that can improve safety, reduce fall risk, and support independence without requiring a complete remodel.
When a Zero-Entry Shower Makes Sense
Although many people can safely continue using a traditional bathtub or shower with the right modifications, there are situations where a zero-entry shower should be considered.
It may be the best long-term option when:
- Wheelchair access is needed now or anticipated in the future.
- A progressive neurological or mobility condition is expected to change functional abilities over time.
- The existing bathroom layout creates significant safety concerns that cannot be addressed through adaptive equipment alone.
When planning a major renovation, considering both current and future needs can help prevent additional remodeling later.
Practical Alternatives to a Complete Shower Remodel
For many households, relatively simple modifications can provide meaningful improvements in safety while remaining considerably more affordable than a complete renovation.
1. Tub Cut-Outs
A tub cut-out lowers the height of the bathtub wall by removing a section and installing a watertight insert. This reduces the height someone must step over when entering and exiting the tub while preserving much of the existing bathtub.
Tub cut-outs can be useful when the primary barrier is stepping over a high bathtub wall, but an individual can otherwise safely stand and move within the shower.
Tub cut-out kits are available for purchase. However, installation is best completed by a qualified professional or an exceptionally skilled homeowner to ensure the modification is structurally sound, properly sealed, and safe for long-term use.
A tub cut-out does not automatically make a bathtub wheelchair accessible. It is important to evaluate the individual's abilities and the remaining threshold before selecting this option.
2. Tub Transfer Benches
Transfer benches allow an individual to sit outside the bathtub and slide into the shower instead of stepping over a high tub wall.
They can:
- Reduce the need to balance on one leg while stepping over the tub.
- Improve confidence during bathing transfers.
- Support individuals recovering from surgery or experiencing balance impairments.
- Be removed if no longer needed.
For many people, a transfer bench is one of the most cost-effective accessibility solutions available.
However, a transfer bench must fit the bathroom layout and the individual's transfer abilities. The location of the toilet, shower doors, grab bars, and available floor space can all affect whether a bench will work appropriately.
3. Specialized Transfer Systems
Individuals with more complex mobility needs may benefit from specialized transfer systems that provide additional positioning and transfer support.
Products such as ShowerBuddy offer options designed to support bathing and toileting for individuals with more significant mobility limitations.
These systems may be particularly helpful for people who require caregiver assistance or use more advanced mobility equipment.
Because specialized transfer equipment can involve multiple components and specific transfer techniques, professional evaluation and training are important before use.
Product Spotlight: A Shower Curtain Designed for Transfer Benches
One common concern with tub transfer benches is water escaping onto the bathroom floor.
Unlike a traditional shower chair that sits completely inside the bathtub, a transfer bench extends beyond the tub wall. This allows someone to sit outside the tub before moving across the bench, but it can make it difficult to keep a standard shower curtain closed.
A shower curtain specifically designed for transfer benches can help address this problem.
These curtains typically include overlapping openings that allow the bench to extend outside the bathtub while helping contain water inside the shower area.
Benefits may include:
- Reducing water accumulation on the bathroom floor.
- Allowing a transfer bench to remain in place during bathing.
- Improving convenience for individuals and caregivers.
- Providing an affordable solution without structural bathroom changes.
Medline and other manufacturers offer bathroom equipment and accessories designed to support safer bathing.
Example equipment: View a tub transfer bench example.
When selecting a shower curtain or transfer bench, confirm compatibility with the existing bathtub and equipment.
The Role of Occupational Therapy in Bathroom Modifications
Occupational therapists can provide valuable guidance long before construction begins.
Rather than focusing solely on equipment, occupational therapy considers how an individual actually moves through the bathroom, identifying opportunities to improve safety while planning for future needs.
An occupational therapist may:
- Evaluate functional mobility and transfer techniques.
- Recommend bathroom layouts that better support independence.
- Collaborate with contractors during renovation planning.
- Help ensure equipment and home modifications work together effectively.
- Consider long-term accessibility needs as physical abilities change.
Early involvement can help prevent costly mistakes and support informed decisions that continue to meet an individual's needs over time.
A Practical Example: Improving Bathroom Safety in a Rental Home
Consider an older adult living with arthritis and balance limitations who finds it increasingly difficult to step over the bathtub wall safely.
Because the individual lives in a rental apartment, permanent renovations are not an option. The goal is to identify affordable changes that improve safety while respecting the limitations of the property.
Following an occupational therapy assessment, several practical strategies might be recommended:
- Transfer bench: Allows seated entry into the bathtub rather than stepping over the tub wall.
- Transfer bench shower curtain: Helps keep water inside the bathtub during bathing.
- Community equipment loan program: May provide access to equipment without the full cost of purchasing it.
- Appropriate transfer support: A professionally evaluated and securely installed support option may improve stability when standing or repositioning.
Together, these relatively inexpensive interventions can make bathing more manageable while reducing the need for major renovations.
The example illustrates an important lesson: improving accessibility does not always require a significant construction project. Thoughtful equipment selection and individualized problem-solving can often achieve meaningful improvements with a modest investment.
Planning for Today and Tomorrow
Not every bathroom needs to be completely remodeled to support aging in place.
For some households, relatively inexpensive equipment provides the support needed to continue bathing safely. For others, a more comprehensive renovation may be the better long-term investment.
The key is understanding how the bathroom is used today, what challenges exist, and how needs may change over time.
At Happy at Home Consulting, we help individuals and families evaluate home accessibility, explore practical modifications, and make informed decisions about maintaining independence at home.
Products and equipment referenced in this article are provided for educational purposes and are not endorsements. Equipment selection, installation, and transfer techniques should be based on individual needs and reviewed with qualified professionals when appropriate. Product availability and pricing may change.